A letter from a reader Evelyn S – The Clarke Family

A letter from a reader Evelyn S

A Letter From a Reader

At 63 I bought a dress in orange, and I have not stopped hearing about it.

On the knit dress that comes in five colors nobody my age is supposed to wear — buttons up to the throat or falls open, and needs nothing over it.

Sandra Thompson
By Sandra Thompson · Mount Pleasant, South Carolina
Posted August 2026 · 6 min read
The Evelyn Knit Polo Dress worn full length
The Evelyn in orange — the one I was not going to buy.

I am 63, and at some point I had quietly agreed to a rule nobody ever said out loud. Navy, gray, black, and beige if I was feeling adventurous. Anything with actual color in it was for younger women, or for people who wanted to be looked at, and I had decided I was neither.

The result was a closet you could photograph in black and white and lose nothing.

It was my daughter Sarah, up in Boston, who told me to stop settling and look at a knit dress from a small family boutique here in South Carolina. She sent me the orange one on purpose. Before I tell you what it did, I think you should read the Clarke family's letter first.

The Clarke family runs a small boutique here in South Carolina, family-run since 1986 — three generations, mother to daughter. The dress is called the Evelyn, and their letter walks through the handful of things they refused to compromise on. I am going to let their words carry it, because they say it better than I could.

1The collar gives you two dresses

The standing ribbed collar and short button placket of the Evelyn

The collar is knitted to stand on its own, with a short placket and three buttons at the front. Done up, it closes to the throat and covers the neck like a sweater would. Left open, it falls into a soft V that draws the eye up towards your face. Same dress, two entirely different necklines, and the only decision you have to make in the morning.

★★★★★"Buttoned up for the school run, open for lunch. Nobody has worked out it is the same dress."Diane M., Greenville SC

2Knitted heavy enough to need nothing over it

Most knit dresses are cut thin, which means a cardigan goes over the top and you are dressing in pieces again. We knitted the Evelyn at a proper weight so it stands on its own indoors, and a coat goes straight over it when you go out. One garment, warm from the first minute, and nothing to keep taking off and losing.

★★★★★"No cardigan needed, which is new for me. It is warm the moment I put it on."Linda K., Beaufort SC

3Deep ribbing, where knitwear usually gives up

The ribbed knit cuff of the Evelyn

The cuffs and the hem are finished with a deep rib rather than the shallow band most knitwear uses. A shallow rib stretches out within a season and then the sleeves hang open at the wrist and the hem flares where it should not. This one holds its shape wash after wash, which is the difference between two winters and five.

★★★★★"Third winter and the cuffs have not gone soft. My last knit dress lasted one."Janet S., Bluffton SC

4It ends just below the knee, on purpose

The ribbed hem of the Evelyn with boots below it

The hem sits just below the knee, which covers the knee itself and leaves room for a boot without the two fighting each other. Shorter and you are making a decision about your legs every morning. Longer and it needs a heel to look right. This length works with a flat boot, and that is the whole point of it.

★★★★★"Perfect with tall boots and no heels required. At 68 that matters more than it used to."Carol R., Charleston SC

5Nothing at the waist to draw a line

The Evelyn falling straight from the shoulder as she walks

There is no seam at the waist, no belt and no elastic. The Evelyn falls straight from the shoulder and skims past the middle without touching it. That is the reason a heavy knit works at all on a fuller figure — the weight of the cloth carries it down in one clean line instead of settling anywhere.

★★★★★"Nothing sits on my stomach and nothing pulls when I sit down. I forget I have it on."Patricia L., Columbia SC

6Five colors, and a size for you — XS to 3XL

The Evelyn comes in orange, red, black, beige and yellow. We know exactly which two of those most women reach for first, and we made the other three anyway, because a good knit dress is the safest possible place to wear a real color — the shape is quiet, so the color does not have to be. Sizes run XS through 3XL. If you are between sizes, take the smaller one.

★★★★★"I ordered the black and wore the orange one my sister bought. I have since ordered the orange."Maureen T., Summerville SC

The Evelyn, against the knit dresses you've been buying

The usual knit dress The Evelyn
The neck One neckline, and that is that Buttons to the throat or falls open
What you need with it A cardigan over the top Nothing — it is heavy enough alone
The waist A seam or elastic that draws a line Falls straight from the shoulder
Cuffs and hem A shallow rib that stretches out Deep ribbing that holds its shape
The colors Navy, gray, black Five, and three of them are real
The usual knit dress
  • One neckline, and that is that
  • Needs a cardigan over the top
  • A seam or elastic that draws a line
  • A shallow rib that stretches out
  • Navy, gray, black
The Evelyn
  • Buttons to the throat or falls open
  • Heavy enough to wear alone
  • Falls straight from the shoulder
  • Deep ribbing that holds its shape
  • Five colors, and three of them are real

Why they're clearing it now

The Clarke family outside their South Carolina boutique

They priced the Evelyn at $164.95 when it launched, and it sold at that price all season. But for America's 250th, the Clarke family wanted to give something back to the women who have kept their doors open since 1986 — so every dress is going out at well below half of what it was.

Mine arrived a few days later in a kraft parcel with a short handwritten note tucked in beside it. I held the orange up to the window for a good while before I was brave enough to put it on.

The Evelyn just arrived, held up by the window

The Evelyn Dress

★★★★★ 4.7 / 5 from 6,247+ reviews
$164.95$64.95
America's 250th Sale — Save 60%
  • A standing collar that buttons to the throat or falls open
  • Knitted heavy enough to wear with nothing over it
  • No waist seam, no belt — it falls straight from the shoulder
  • Deep ribbed cuffs and hem that hold their shape
  • 5 colors · sizes XS–3XL · Free UPS shipping · 30-day money-back guarantee
See if your size is still in stock →

The Evelyn Dress · $64.95 while sizes last

America's 250th Anniversary Sale ends tonight.
Buy 2 get 10%, buy 3 get 15%, buy 4 get an extra 20% off. When it's gone, it's gone.
Free ShippingSent with UPS, on us
30-Day ReturnsMoney-back guarantee
Since 1986Family-owned in South Carolina

I do not usually write things like this. But I had spent about a decade quietly agreeing that color was for other people, and it took one dress to work out that nobody had ever actually said so. If your closet has gone the same way mine had, I hope you find your size before it clears.

— Sandra Thompson · Mount Pleasant, SC

See the Evelyn — $64.95 →

This is a personal account from a Clarke Family customer. Sandra was not paid to write it. · The Clarke Family · Family Fashion · South Carolina, since 1986 · Free UPS shipping · 30-day money-back guarantee.

A letter from a reader Evelyn S